I had the privilege to drive the 818 Tom built for over 100 miles today. Being a GTM owner I felt I could give a seat of the pants perspective, comparing the 2. Very similar p/w.
The GTM feels faster, though the Tq and sound has a lot to do with that.
On the street the 818 can extract more fun.
The GTM gets more Highway stares.
The 818 would be far easier as a DD.
The turbo is down right awesome when the BOV opens up.
The power delivery is soooooooo different.
Both have huge blind spots.
Very different cars, neither better then the other. The 818 as at the removable top but the GTM has heat and a/c. I would want both but if I could only afford one, boy that would be hard.