I've been tracking everything I've sold off the donor. My donor was an 06 WRX which has a few items that are more desireable than other model years for resale (ex: integrated headrest seats vs 02/03 standard headrest, painted side skirts vs 02-05 black plastic, painted mirrors vs 06 TR black mirrors).
Car was in a front right impact. Most of front end was ruined, drivers light and fender were undamaged.
Prices listed are what things actually sold for. The second price is what it cost to ship it if it wasn't a local pickup. Some prices aren't even numbers because people are bad at math and don't add in the 3% paypal when asked and I can't remember the original value.
This should help give others an idea of what they can recoup. Keep in mind, you might get more, but I went more for the quicker sale than holding onto items for months. Other items I didn't sell due to shipping (ie: trunk).
Total so far is $1995.65 in parts sold, $140.19 for shipping, so a net decrease in the cost of my donor of $1855.46. Original cost of donor: $4095. Current cost of donor: $2239.54.
*Headliner: $30
*Rear Strut Bar (aftermarket): $25
*All Weather Subaru floor mats: $20
*Visors (cloth, not vinyl like 02-?): $5
*Rally Armor mudflaps (aftermarket): $65, $12 shipping
*Taillights (06 stock) and hood struts (aftermarket): $208, $19 shipping
*Custom header tank bracket: $54, $3 shipping
*Painted STI style sideskirts (stock on 06): $165, $26 shipping
*Front Seats (integrated headrest, stock 06): $225
*Cabin carpet and fog lights (no fog bezel): $220, $58 shipping
*Fender: $50
*Spare tire: $15
* Painted sideview mirrors (stock): $90, $14 shipping
*Aluminum battery tie down (aftermarket): $25, $1.50 shipping
*Plastic power steering reservoir: $30, $5 shipping
*Scrap metal, Steel: $75
*Scrap metal, aluminum (included old intake manifold): $20
Items I haven't/didn't sell due to high shipping cost or people never showed up:
*trunk: Stock with CF OEM style WRX wing : $200, didn't want to ship to california.
*Roof skin: $180 (guy didn't show up, needs to replace his, dealer wants $300 for unpainted skin).
*Doors: $50 for metal skins only (same guy, didn't show up)
*Rear quarter panels: $50 (different guy changed his mind when he realized all the work to weld them onto a wagon).